What If Financial Resilience Became A Collective Responsibility?

What Would Our World Look Like?

Before you cry, "not another nanny state evangelist", this isn't about that.

It's not my problem - It's not your problem.

It's our problem.

And before deciding whether you agree, look at the numbers below. Then ask yourself is standing entirely alone a realistic proposition for any of us in the future.

I've spent most of my career trying to find better outcomes hidden inside imperfect situations. Not by assigning blame, and not by picking sides, but by asking whether there's a way for everyone to leave better off than they arrived.

This is one of those situations because when you put the numbers side by side, you only see one problem. You don't see eight separate problems that are impacting on our lives on a daily basis.


The Numbers We Can't Ignore

Pensions. Ten years ago, around 38% of working-age people were under-saving for retirement. Today that figure stands at 43%, meaning around 15 million people are currently under-saving, and we're on course to reach 19 million. By 2036, we risk a generation retiring with less private income than their parents and a greater dependence on the State Pension.

Buffer savings. Ten years ago, most households had at least a modest financial buffer, however fragile. Today, one in ten adults has no cash savings at all, while another 21% have less than £1,000 set aside. By 2036, a broken boiler, a missed shift or an unexpected car repair could become a debt crisis for millions.

Benefits. Around a decade ago, a benefits bill of £220 billion was already viewed as high. Today it stands at £333.7 billion, representing 10.6% of GDP, and is forecast to reach £431 billion by 2031/32.

Household debt. Excluding mortgages, household debt averaged around £10,300 per household in 2016. Today that figure is approximately £19,659, an increase of around 90% in just ten years. Debt is rising faster than wages as more people borrow simply to stand still.

Insolvencies. A decade ago, annual insolvencies hovered around 100,000 and were viewed as relatively stable. Today, England and Wales have recorded 34,303 insolvencies in a single quarter, placing us on course for sustained levels exceeding 130,000 each year.

Home repossessions. Ten years ago, repossessions were at historic lows and widely regarded as a problem largely solved. Today they are rising once again, with a gradual return to levels many thought had been left behind.

Personal taxation. Throughout much of the 2010s, the tax burden represented around 33% of national income. Today it stands between 36% and 37%, the highest level since 1948, and is forecast to reach 38.6%, a peacetime record, before the end of the decade.

The Shameful Seven, but don't read this as a list, read it as a direction of travel.

Look at those seven measures again.

Individually, each could be dismissed as a separate challenge.

Together, they tell a different story.

Not one is moving in the right direction.

And perhaps most importantly, none of them exists in isolation.

The Frog In The Pan of Water

For many people, the change isn't dramatic enough to notice. An extra £20 more on a mortgage, Council Tax up by £15. Ongoing frozen tax threshold quietly pulling somebody into a higher tax band without a meaningful improvement in living standards. Add in a pension contribution remaining at 4% because nobody ever explained that 4% just isn’t going to cut it.

You don't feel the water getting hotter, you simply get used to it.

That's not foolishness, it’s human nature.

That's life getting in the way.

But while individuals absorb a little more pressure each year, the system feels the cumulative effect. The balance between those contributing and those needing increasing levels of support begins to shift.

Slowly at first, and then all at once.

We've Already Paid For The Answer

And here's the part that frustrates me most, we haven't ignored these issues, far from it.

Over the last decade, banks, employers, charities, schools, policymakers, regulators and countless dedicated individuals have invested enormous amounts of time, money and effort into improving financial capability.

From Financial education in schools and Workplace wellbeing programmes, to Budgeting tools and Debt advice services. Thousands upon thousands of hours of genuine, well-intentioned work, and that work matters. It has helped millions of people, and still is helping.

But if we improve capability without improving the environment in which that capability is exercised, we risk wasting much of that effort.

You can teach somebody how to budget, but if they have no buffer, no margin and no room for error, what exactly are they expected to budget with?

You can teach somebody about pensions, but if contributions remain inadequate and future pressures keep increasing, what exactly are they expected to do with that knowledge?

You can teach somebody about debt, but if the easiest path remains the most expensive path, and complexity continues to overwhelm, have we really changed the outcome?

Or have we simply helped them understand why they're stuck?

Good intentions without structural progress become little more than lectures, and lectures don't build resilience.

We have spent years improving the players.

Perhaps the next challenge is improving the pitch.

Otherwise, ten years from now, we'll be holding another Talk Money Week, looking at another set of worsening numbers, and wondering why all that effort didn't move the dial far enough.

Here's The Rub

Many people will reasonably look at all of this and conclude:

"I'll be alright."

I understand that feeling, I've felt it myself and to a certain degree still do.

But here's the uncomfortable reality.

You can't be alright in a society where millions are falling behind.

You can't be alright if the benefits bill continues growing faster than the economy, because somebody will ultimately pay for it.

You can't be alright if millions of people have little or no financial resilience, because when they hit crisis, that crisis doesn't just stay with them.

It comes into the our workplaces, it leans on public services, it spreads into our communities as well as hitting tax payers. And eventually it reaches all of us.You cannot sustain a society where growing numbers feel disconnected, excluded and without hope, while assuming everyone else will somehow remain unaffected.

The water boils for everyone.

So What Do We Do?

This is usually where accusations of a nanny state begin, and It is also where I think they miss the point. Collective responsibility isn't about government controlling people's lives. It's about recognising that financial resilience can no longer be treated as an individual challenge when so many of the forces shaping it are collective.

In a previous article, I suggested one example of the kind of thinking we might need: an independent Financial Resilience Fund, financed through a small share of value created by financial inertia.

Not as charity, not as punishment, and certainly not as another tax. But as one example of how we might invest upstream rather than continually paying for failure downstream. Whether that idea is right or wrong is almost secondary.

The bigger point is that we need to start looking for solutions that build resilience before crisis occurs.

Solutions that help people develop buffers before they need benefits.

Capability before they need debt advice.

Confidence before they become overwhelmed.

Hope before they give up.

A Different Question

I don't believe most people struggle because they lack intelligence, nor do they struggle because they don't care.

They're busy, life is complicated and priorities compete.

Doing nothing often isn't a conscious decision at all, it's simply what happens when everything else gets in the way. But we do have a choice in how we respond to that reality.

We can continue telling people to try harder, save more and somehow become more resilient while the numbers continue moving in the wrong direction. Or we can recognise that financial resilience has become a collective responsibility.

Not because we want to infantilise people or we want to remove personal responsibility. But because resilience, like infrastructure, works best when everyone contributes to building it. Because ultimately this isn't about money, it's about hope.

And a society without hope is a society where none of us get to be truly OK.

Financial resilience is no longer just a personal ambition.

It is becoming a national necessity.

And the question isn't whether we'll respond together.

It's whether we'll do it before the water gets much hotter.

Next
Next

When Financial Inertia Creates Value